Table of Contents
- What Are the Limitations on Expungement? Crimes That Can’t Be Cleared
- Crimes That Cannot Be Expunged
- Violent Crimes
- Sex Offenses
- Crimes Against Minors
- Serious Felonies
- DUI and DWI Offenses
- How State Expungement Laws Differ
- States with Strict Expungement Laws
- States Leading in Expungement Reforms
- Automatic vs. Petition-Based Expungement
- Federal Crimes and Expungement Challenges
- The Economic and Social Impact of Expungement Limitations
- Economic Barriers to Opportunity
- Social Inequities in Expungement Access
- The Persistent Problem of Digital Records
- The Role of Attorneys in Expungement Success
- Higher Success Rates with Legal Assistance
- Pro Bono Services and Legal Clinics
- Conclusion: Why Expungement Limitations Matter
Ready to Publish
Ready to Publish
Author
OG Image (1200x630)
Excerpt
Expungement can provide individuals with a second chance by sealing or erasing their criminal records, but it's essential to understand the limitations on which crimes can be cleared. This blog post explores the types of offenses that typically cannot be expunged and highlights the importance of seeking the assistance of an experienced attorney near you to navigate this complex process effectively.
Meta Description
Discover the limitations of expungement and learn which crimes cannot be cleared from your record. Understand the importance of legal representation in navigating the expungement process and find an attorney near you to help you secure a second chance at a brighter future.
Slug
criminal/expungement-and-sealing-of-records/limitations-expungement-crimes-not-cleared
Alt Image Text
Illustration representing expungement limitations, featuring a denied and approved expungement request, a judge reviewing the case, and individuals reacting to their legal outcomes, with a courthouse in the background.
Related Posts
Global Tags
Parent item
Sub-item
Hide in Main Feed
Hide in Main Feed
Post Id
968
Updated
Feb 26, 2025 09:34 PM
Featured
Featured
Hide CTA
Hide CTA
Hide Cover
Hide Cover
What Are the Limitations on Expungement? Crimes That Can’t Be Cleared
Expungement—the process of sealing or erasing criminal records—can open doors to better employment, housing, and a brighter future. For many individuals, it offers a second chance to move beyond the stigma of a criminal record. However, not all crimes are eligible for expungement. Some offenses are deemed too severe or harmful to warrant this legal remedy. Understanding these limitations is crucial for anyone seeking to clear their record.
In this article, we’ll explore the crimes typically excluded from expungement, how state and federal laws differ, and why legal representation is often essential to navigate this complex process.
Crimes That Cannot Be Expunged
While expungement laws vary by state, some types of crimes are almost universally excluded. These exclusions reflect a balance between public safety and the potential for rehabilitation.
Violent Crimes
Offenses involving serious harm or the threat of harm, such as murder, aggravated assault, or armed robbery, are rarely eligible for expungement. Courts often prioritize public safety over the offender’s need for a clean slate. For example, a conviction for murder carries a societal weight that most jurisdictions are unwilling to overlook. These limitations are consistent with the broader aim of ensuring accountability for crimes that cause profound and lasting harm (AL Faraguna, Brook. L. Rev., 2016).
Sex Offenses
Sexual crimes, particularly those involving minors, are another category commonly excluded from expungement. Convictions for offenses like rape, sexual assault, or possession of child pornography are typically ineligible due to their sensitive nature and the societal interest in protecting vulnerable populations. Many states prohibit sealing these records to ensure public awareness and safety.
Crimes Against Minors
Offenses involving the abuse, endangerment, or exploitation of children—such as child abuse or human trafficking—are universally excluded. Courts regard these crimes as particularly egregious, with the potential for lifelong trauma to the victims. As a result, they are rarely considered for expungement, even in states with relatively lenient laws.
Serious Felonies
Felonies involving large-scale harm or extensive criminal activity, such as drug trafficking, organized crime, or terrorism-related offenses, are also typically ineligible. These crimes often affect not just individuals but entire communities, making expungement a less viable option (MJ Yee, Geo. J. on Poverty L. & Pol’y, 2017).
DUI and DWI Offenses
Driving under the influence (DUI) or driving while intoxicated (DWI) is another gray area in expungement law. While some states allow these convictions to be sealed, many do not, citing the recurring nature of these offenses and their significant impact on public safety (JC Dugan, Ind. LJ, 2015).
How State Expungement Laws Differ
The patchwork of state laws governing expungement creates significant variation in eligibility and process. While some states have implemented progressive reforms, others remain restrictive.
States with Strict Expungement Laws
States like Alabama and Arizona maintain stringent eligibility criteria. In Alabama, for instance, expungement is available only for charges—not convictions. Arizona, meanwhile, offers a “set aside” process, which releases individuals from penalties but does not erase their records (Wikipedia on Expungement).
States Leading in Expungement Reforms
On the other end of the spectrum, states like California and Indiana have embraced reforms aimed at broadening access to expungement. Indiana’s comprehensive reforms led to a 60% increase in expungement applications, reflecting greater accessibility and public awareness (BM Murray, Harv. L. & Pol’y Rev., 2016).
Automatic vs. Petition-Based Expungement
Some states, such as Michigan, have introduced automatic expungement, where eligible records are cleared without requiring individuals to file a petition. This removes barriers for those unable to navigate the legal system. By contrast, petition-based systems—still the norm in most states—demand significant effort and resources from applicants (Z Callison, Lux et Fides Journal, 2024).
Federal Crimes and Expungement Challenges
At the federal level, the expungement landscape is even more restrictive. Unlike states, the federal government does not have a comprehensive statute allowing for the sealing or erasure of criminal records. Instead, individuals must rely on limited remedies, such as presidential pardons, which forgive but do not erase convictions. These pardons are rare and often granted only in exceptional circumstances (Justice Department Overview).
Additionally, federal expungement attempts face a 70% rejection rate, primarily due to procedural hurdles and the limited scope of eligibility (AL Faraguna, Brook. L. Rev., 2016).
The Economic and Social Impact of Expungement Limitations
The inability to expunge certain records has far-reaching consequences, not just for the individuals directly affected but also for society at large. These limitations perpetuate economic inequality, hinder social reintegration, and contribute to systemic injustices.
Economic Barriers to Opportunity
A criminal record often acts as a barrier to employment, housing, and education, even long after the sentence has been served. Expungement can alleviate these challenges, significantly improving economic prospects for individuals.
• Research shows that individuals who successfully expunge their records experience an average annual income increase of $6,000 (Z Callison, Lux et Fides Journal, 2024).
• Without expungement, former offenders are often relegated to low-paying jobs or face prolonged unemployment, perpetuating cycles of poverty.
Social Inequities in Expungement Access
The costs associated with expungement, including court fees and attorney expenses, create significant barriers for low-income individuals.
• States with fee waivers report a 35% higher expungement rate among low-income applicants (CC Armstrong, Rutgers UL Rev., 2021).
• Those unable to afford the process are effectively excluded from its benefits, deepening existing inequalities.
The Persistent Problem of Digital Records
Even when expungement is granted, the rise of digital recordkeeping complicates the process. Many expunged records remain accessible through online databases and digital brokers, undermining the intended benefits of sealing records.
• A 2019 study found that over 65% of expunged records could still be accessed through third-party digital platforms (G Koerner & H Kettani, ACM Proceedings, 2019).
This persistence of records highlights the need for stronger enforcement of digital privacy standards and more robust expungement mechanisms.
The Role of Attorneys in Expungement Success
The expungement process is complex, with strict legal requirements and procedural hurdles. Legal representation can make a significant difference in the outcome of an expungement application.
Higher Success Rates with Legal Assistance
Individuals represented by an attorney are far more likely to succeed in their expungement efforts.
• Statistics show an 82% success rate for applications filed with attorney assistance, compared to just 37% for self-represented individuals (AF Kimpel, The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 2022).
Attorneys ensure that applications are complete, timely, and meet all legal standards, minimizing the risk of rejection.
Pro Bono Services and Legal Clinics
For those unable to afford legal fees, pro bono services and legal clinics offer a lifeline.
• Clinics using volunteer attorneys improve expungement success rates by 50%, demonstrating the value of accessible legal aid (A Myrick, Law & Society Review, 2013).
These programs are particularly critical for marginalized communities disproportionately affected by the criminal justice system.
Conclusion: Why Expungement Limitations Matter
Expungement offers a pathway to a better future for many individuals, but its limitations leave others trapped by their criminal records.
• Crimes such as violent offenses, sexual crimes, and serious felonies are often excluded from expungement eligibility, reflecting a balance between public safety and rehabilitation.
• The patchwork of state and federal laws creates significant disparities in access, with financial and procedural barriers further disadvantaging low-income individuals.
If you or a loved one are seeking to expunge a criminal record, legal guidance is essential. The process can be daunting, but an experienced attorney can dramatically improve your chances of success. ReferU.AI offers a free service to connect you with skilled expungement attorneys who can help you navigate this challenging process. Take the first step toward a fresh start today.
Written by
